DIY Collagen Toners: Dermatologists Warn Against This Viral Skincare Trend

 

A bottle of cloves filled with glycerine

⚠️ DIY “Collagen Toners” From Instagram and Facebook, other social media: A Dangerous Trend Backed by Misinformation — Dermatologists Explain the Real Truth

In recent years, Instagram skincare pages have exploded with “magic” recipes promising instant collagen, wrinkle removal, and dramatic age reversal. One viral recipe claims that a “47-year-old mom looks 18” because she applies a homemade “collagen toner” made from cloves, flaxseeds, rosewater, glycerin, green-tea infusion, aloe vera, and vitamin E oil. The problem? None of these ingredients can produce collagen, and several can seriously irritate or damage the skin.

This article breaks down the misinformation, explains the science behind real collagen production, and highlights why bloggers and influencers must stop spreading unsafe DIY skincare concoctions that risk people’s health.

🔍 False Claim 1: “This toner boosts collagen and reverses aging.”

This statement is biologically impossible.

What dermatologists say

Human skin cannot absorb collagen from topical products, especially not from cloves or flaxseed. Collagen molecules are far too large to penetrate the epidermis. Even skincare products marketed as “collagen creams” do not actually create collagen; at best, they hydrate.

What actually boosts collagen

Only a few ingredients have scientific evidence:

  • Retinoids (retinol, tretinoin)

  • Vitamin C (L-ascorbic acid)

  • Peptides

  • Niacinamide

  • Sunscreen (prevents collagen breakdown)

  • Professional treatments like microneedling, RF, laser resurfacing

None of these are in the Instagram recipe.

❌ Ingredient-by-Ingredient Scientific Breakdown

Let’s examine each ingredient in the viral “collagen toner” recipe:

1: Cloves (Laung)

Cloves contain eugenol, a strong aromatic compound used in dentistry as a numbing agent.
But on facial skin, it is highly irritating.

Scientific concerns

Dermatology literature shows:

  • Causes contact dermatitis

  • Can trigger chemical burns

  • Increases photosensitivity

  • Disrupts skin barrier because of its strong essential-oil-like potency

Result: Redness, burning, hyperpigmentation, and sensitivity, especially in people with brown skin.

There is no scientific evidence supporting cloves for collagen.

2: Flaxseeds

Flaxseeds release a mucilage gel when boiled. While this gel can feel soothing as a hair gel or temporary moisturizer, it is not stable and not dermatologically approved for toners.

What research says

  • Spoils within 24–72 hours, even in the fridge

  • High risk of bacterial growth

  • Can worsen fungal acne (Malassezia)

  • Can clog pores due to its sticky consistency

No evidence shows flaxseed gel stimulates collagen.

3: Rosewater

Rosewater is safe and soothing. Dermatologists approve it for mild hydration.
But it cannot offset the irritation of cloves or the instability of flaxseed gel.

4: Vegetable Glycerin

A great humectant — but only when used in low concentration and combined with preservatives.

In DIY toners:

  • It can become too sticky

  • Attracts bacteria without preservatives

  • Can cause congestion in humid climates

5: Vitamin E Capsule Oil

Vitamin E is beneficial but oily and comedogenic, meaning it can clog pores.

Problems in this recipe

  • Oil does not mix with rosewater

  • Separates and floats on top

  • Increases chances of acne and blackheads

6: Green-tea Infusion

Green tea is rich in antioxidants and is actually a beneficial ingredient when used correctly.

But again, the overall formulation is unsafe due to lack of preservatives and presence of irritants.

7: Aloe Vera Juice

Hydrating and soothing — only if pure, clean, and properly preserved.
DIY aloe or supermarket aloe drinks are not suitable for skin.

🚫 The Biggest Problem: No Preservatives

This DIY toner combines:

  • Water

  • Plants

  • Seeds

  • Tea

  • Aloe

Any mixture containing water + plant extracts becomes a perfect breeding ground for bacteria, mold, and yeast within 24 hours.

Dermatologists warn:

“Unpreserved DIY skincare grows microbes that the naked eye cannot see. Applying spoiled liquid can cause infections and dermatitis.”

This makes the recipe dangerous even if the ingredients were safe individually.

🔥 The Harm of Instagram Skincare Misinformation

Many pages use catchy phrases like:

  • “Mom looks 18 at 47”

  • “Dermatologist secret”

  • “Magic toner for instant glow”

  • “Collagen booster recipe”

These claims are:

  • Unscientific

  • Misleading

  • Potentially harmful

They target vulnerable people who are desperate for anti-aging results and trust viral content without understanding the risks.

Influencers must understand the ethical responsibility that comes with giving skincare advice.

💔 How Misinformation Hurts People

Women often report:

  • Increased hyperpigmentation

  • Chemical burns

  • Severe irritation

  • Long-term barrier damage

  • Acne flare-ups

  • Sensitivity that requires dermatologist treatment

The emotional impact is huge:

  • Loss of self-esteem

  • Feeling deceived

  • Financial burden of repairing damage

Skincare is not entertainment — it is health, and misinformation can ruin someone’s skin for months or years.

🔬 What Dermatologists Actually Recommend Instead

If someone wants an anti-aging, hydrating toner, dermatologists suggest:

  • Hyaluronic acid toners

  • Niacinamide 2–5% toners

  • Green tea toners (properly formulated)

  • Rice water toners (with preservatives)

  • Peptide toners

These are lab-tested, stable, safe, and free from harmful deception.

💡 The Truth: No DIY Toner Can Replace Science

While DIY skincare feels natural and appealing, it cannot:

  • Boost collagen

  • Erase wrinkles

  • Reverse aging

  • Replace clinical treatments

Only scientifically proven ingredients can do that.

⚠️ Strong Warning

People must stop applying untested kitchen ingredients to their skin, especially those with fragrances, eugenol, or unstable plant gels.

Brown and Asian skin tones are especially vulnerable to:

  • PIH (dark spots after irritation)

  • Burns

  • Long-lasting discoloration

What may give a short-term glow can cause long-term damage.

✔ Safe Alternatives for a “Glowing Anti-Aging Toner”

A safe formula includes:

  • Green tea extract

  • Hyaluronic acid

  • Panthenol

  • Niacinamide

  • Glycerin (very small amount)

  • A proper preservative

If you want, I can create a professional dermatologist-safe toner recipe for your blog.

⚠ DISCLAIMER 

This article is for informational and educational purposes only.
DIY skincare recipes circulating on Instagram, TikTok, and other platforms are not medically tested, not regulated, and may cause irritation, infection, or permanent skin damage. Always consult a licensed dermatologist before applying any homemade product to your face. The author and website do not take responsibility for misuse, allergic reactions, or adverse effects caused by attempting any unverified skincare routines.

Creamy DIY Body Scrub: Achieve Spa-Soft Skin Effortlessly

Hi, I’m Waterlily. I write educational skincare content to help people understand their skin better through simple, honest, and awareness-focused information.

Comments

Post a Comment